For Sale Property MLS# 1036053

272 Broadway

Bethpage, NY 11714

$1,400,000

onekey_mls logo

About 272 Broadway

Exceptional mixed-use investment property offering strong income potential and significant upside. Situated on a 9,000 sq. ft. lot with approximately 3,221 sq. ft. of rentable space, this well-maintained building consists of one ground-floor retail unit and two fully renovated two-bedroom apartments on the second level.

The residential units were completely renovated approximately four months ago and feature gas-fired central heating and air conditioning, providing modern comfort and efficiency for tenants. The retail space and basement are serviced by oil-fired hot water heat and wall-mounted air conditioning units.

The property also includes a full basement offering ample storage space, a detached two-bay commercial garage, and an on-site 12-car parking lot, providing excellent convenience for both residential and commercial occupants.

Each unit is separately metered for electricity, allowing tenants to pay their own electric, gas and oil utilities bill. The building is serviced by 200-amp electrical service.

Investment Highlights Mixed-use building with 1 retail unit and 2 residential apartments Two renovated 2-bedroom apartments Approximately 3,221 sq. ft. of rentable space 9,000 sq. ft. lot Detached 2-door commercial garage 12 dedicated parking spaces Full basement for storage Separate electric meters for each unit Residential units feature gas central heat and central air Retail space and basement feature oil-fired hot water heat with wall A/C units 200-amp electrical service Tenants pay their own utilities Financial Summary Current Monthly Gross Rental Income: $7,540 Annual Gross Rental Income: $90,480 Annual Operating Expenses (including taxes): $52,449.07 Current Net Operating Income (NOI): $38,030.93

***Utilities*** Taxes- $41,044.86 Annual Sprinkler Alarm System- $1,270.92 Annual Snow Removal- $1,200 Annual Insurance- $7192.08 Annual Internet- $1,575.48 Annual PSEGLI- $65.73 Annual Water- $100 Annual

Rental Incomes Per Unit - Retail Space- $2040 - Apartment 1- $2300 - Apartment 2- $3200 - Garage- $0

The retail space offers the opportunity for rental increases to current market rates, providing investors with the potential to achieve an estimated 7% capitalization rate. With renovated residential units, separate utilities, abundant parking, and additional income potential, this property presents an excellent opportunity for both investors and owner-users seeking stable cash flow with future upside.

******All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified by prospective buyers and their representatives. Property details, including but not limited to square footage, lot size, income, expenses, zoning, permits, taxes, leases, and all other information, are subject to verification. The listing broker and listing agent make no representations or warranties, express or implied, as to the accuracy or completeness of the information provided and assume no responsibility for any errors, omissions, or changes. Buyers are advised to conduct their own due diligence before entering into any agreement**********

Property details

Property

Type
other
Year built
1920
Living area
3,221 sqft
Price / sqft
$435
Lot
0.127 ac
List date
Aug 3, 2026

Schools

District
Bethpage Union Free School District

Location

School district
Bethpage Union Free School District

Ask about this property

Questions on 272 Broadway, Bethpage, NY 11714, or want to see it in person?

Listed by OverSouth LLC

Listing information is provided by the participating MLS / IDX program and is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All information should be independently verified. Equal Housing Opportunity.